Dear
Laura: I just lost my
daughter February 28, 2001. She had depression for seven years and just gave up the
battle. She suffered this pain for seven years. Now my husband and I feel this awful pain
that we have lost her at the age of only 24 years. She was a caring and loving person but
this illness she had was too much to handle anymore. She said she never felt like herself;
she always wanted to be at peace with herself and with God. She is there now. But our
hearts are empty and filled with all this pain of losing her. I never knew losing a child
could be so hard to accept. You want them to come back so much but they are gone and not
knowing why. The hurt is so great you just want it to go away. You think it is a bad dream
and when you wake up everything will be all right but it isn't. You cope day to day but
you know your heart will have this emptiness forever. How do you get through it all? I ask
God and my daughter to help her father and me get through the rest of our lives until we
can be with her some day. I know that there are many other parents out there that have
lost children to sudden death by suicide. How do they handle this loss? Please give me
some answers. [anon.]
Dear Laura: I have been reading your responses to so many
broken hearts. I hope you can help me find some comfort. I lost my son tragically a little
over a year ago. I start my day realizing my loss as if it just happened. I am able to put
on a strong front during the day at work but end my day as I began it: hopeless and
heartsick. My grief has changed how I think and react to everything around me. I
am becoming a different person and am not sure it is someone I like. I hope that
the future will bring moments of joy and pleasure again but I also know they will be
lacking because my son is gone. I thought I would be strong for my remaining
children but I find myself unable to help them or myself. I hide my tears as much
as possible from my family and often cry when I'm alone. My son took his own life. There
was no warning and my worth as a mother has suffered tremendously. I don't know what
purpose I serve in life, if what I thought I did best is not so. I understand my
son had to be troubled beyond my understanding to take this action, but I should have
known. I have sought private counseling with little success and find I put on my brave
front when I attended a support group specific to this kind of loss. What next?
While I may never find true happiness again, I need to be there for my husband and
children. What should I do? Thank you, Dr. Laura. You've helped many people. Is there any
help for me? [RS]
Dear RS and
anon(above): I'm
writing this letter to both of you...
Grief evolves. It is never the same from day to day. While it always has a definite
beginning - you will never forget the moment when you heard your tragic news - I can give
you no clear, predictable date for its ending. What I can tell you is that how long this
process of grieving will last and the direction that it will take is up to you. Both of
you are stuck in your grief, each in your own way: one by putting on a strong front; the
other, by clinging to a dream of what was, what could have been. To progress through your
grief, you must confront the pain. Yes, it will hurt, but healing comes through prayer, it
comes through knowledge. You must force yourself - and I know this is asking a lot - to
step aside from your sorrow, if only for a moment; examine where your sadness is taking
you and ask yourself if this is truly what you want. Sometimes, we become so caught up in
our pain that we forget that the physical world is but a part of our total being, that the
beginnings of our future exist here in the present, and that within our deepest sorrow
often lie the seeds of our greatest joy.
Know that what happened to your son and your daughter was beyond your control. Their's was
a personal pain which you never could have shared. But understand that they are at peace
now; allow this be your comfort. Let your belief in the spiritual be the basis for your
healing. Those spiritual gifts of trust and hope are what have helped many move beyond
their sorrow to a deeper understanding of God's plan. And, through understanding, comes a
healing sense of peace and, yes, acceptance.
I'm not saying that you must accept the false idea that you will never see your loved ones
again. On the contrary, you must learn to open your spritual eyes to the fact that their
spirits are in communion with yours at this very moment. It is your sorrow and doubt that
is muffling your awareness of their presence. The acceptance of which we speak is an
acceptance of the eternity of the spirit and the everlasting bonds of love that we build
in this life.
So, take courage; and, with a hopeful heart, reach deep within yourself. Listen to your
intuition: that small, spiritual voice which has guided you in the past. Use it now to
decipher those heavenly messages from the other side of existence. I know that you must
have experienced a sensation of presence recently, but, like many, have passed it off as
imagination or wishful thinking - this definitely is not so. The next time this
happens(and it will), force yourself to pause while listening with your heart. Expect to
hear the voice of an angel, and you will; for heaven is all about us, if only we can open
our hearts to see... Our prayers are definitely with you. Laura
In reply: Dear Laura, I want to thank you for your response to
my plea for help. I think I know in my mind where I should be trying to go but my heart
won't cooperate. I truly believe that hearts can be broken and mine is. I am only
able to think of how my son died and the moment of his death, and not the many years of
laughter and love we shared. Every day, I ask him to come to me and I try to remain
open to those feelings, but I only respond to thoughts of him with tears. Perhaps some
day? I want to be better and will keep trying but this is a difficult road to travel.
Thank you once again for your kind and wise words. I send my thoughts and prayers out to
anyone who has lost a child in this manner and wish you a moment of peace along the way.[RS] Dear Laura: My friend's 26-year-old daughter was killed in a trucking accident[the
tire flew off, jumped the median and hit her front window killing her instantly - so they
say]. Needless to say, they are not doing well. What besides listening can I do? Renee
died March 2nd, 2001. Thank you. [Janet]
Dear Janet: As I said in the above letter, grief is a thing
that evolves. It does not stay the same from day to day. The best that you can do for your
friend is to continue to be the friend which you always have been. Take your cues from
her. Her and her family's needs will change as they move through their grief.
Listening, yes, is a start; though listening can involve more that just hearing the words,
but, also, deciphering their meaning. Is she complaining of not having the energy to fix
dinner? Why not quietly bring over a one-dish meal with no fanfare? If you feel the need
to say anything in response to her protestations, just say, "I wanted to help. You
would have done the same for me." Let love be your guide and you will never go wrong. Laura
Dear Laura: There are things that I would like to resolve with
my ailing mother who lives with us, but she never fails to get very upset and bewildered
that any of what I need to speak of interests me or even matters to me. Do I not speak to
her to spare her any upset in her last times with us and take my questions with me to MY
grave, or do I indulge myself at her expense? These are important
questions that have puzzled me throughout my life, and now is my last chance. What do I
do? [Enigma]
Dear Enigma: Ask yourself honestly: Is knowing really that
important to me AND can I live with the effects this questioning will have on my mother?
This is a serious situation in which you find yourself, but you do have the luxury of time
to decide what would be the best course of action. I suggest that you rehearse before you
act. Envision the results of the two pathways before you. Chose in your mind one,
then the other. Close your eyes. Walk down that chosen pathway to the near future, do you
like what you see? Could you live with the results of your choice? Chose wisely. Trust
your own life's wisdom. You already know inside what you have to do. Laura
Dear Laura: Hi, my name is Tawny and I'm 14 years old. About
two weeks ago, I lost my mom. She was my world and I relied on her so much that it feels I
can't go on. I'm hurting so much and I can't show it. If I hadn't told anyone, they would
have never have known. Another thing is, I can't get it that my mom is dead. I keep
thinking she is going to walk around the corner and tell me it was all a joke and
everything is going to be ok. Please help. Thanx. [Tawny]
Dear Tawny: You're still very much in shock, and denial. You're
going to keep hurting - alone, silently - until you can come to force yourself to open up:
either to someone else(perhaps a trusted friend or relative), or even yourself. Yes, it
will hurt at first - and there will be a lot of tears - but after the tears will come the
healing - it always does. Tawny, you still have much to look forward to in life. Please do
this for yourself, for your mother's memory. Make her proud of you. Become that special
person which I know she always told you you could be. Laura
Dear Laura:
I have had a few close family members die in the past couple of years but the one that I
miss the most I never met: my grandfather. He died when my mom was 14, almost 10 years
before I was born. Recently, I've felt a strong connection with him but I don't know how
to begin to talk to someone I never even knew. This is hard for me to describe. [anon.]
Dear anon:
But you do know him, you know him through your mother. It is not at all uncommon for a
young person to be singled out as the avenue for spiritual communication. There's
something in your personality that is open and receptive which is allowing this to happen.
Why this is happening to you now and not your mother, I don't know. But don't be afraid.
You're not going to see ghosts or anything so theatrical as that but, rather, a spiritual
door appears to be opening.
You can begin by finding a quiet time in the day, calming your thoughts, and focusing
yourself on communicating with your grandfather. Have a question in mind. Repeat it slowly
to yourself, to his spirit. Wait for an answer. Don't be in a rush. It will come. But
listen with your heart, with your intuition, for the message will be very subtle:
sometimes as subtle as just a gentle but definite knowing that he's there with you in
spirit. Yes, it is hard to describe, but, when a spiritual communication happens, there'll
be no denying it to yourself. If you feel comfortable doing so, ask your mother if
she has a message she would like communicated to him.
Do take advantage of this gift that has been given to you. Properly approached, this can
be a very spiritually rewarding time for you and those you love. Laura
Dear Laura: Hi,
my name is Guinevere. I have a little girl who has Rett Syndrome. I need some advice on
the afterlife of a child and I need to ask why I was picked for this hardship in my
life. It seems I have had it so hard all my life, and now God gives me more. I just want
to know why me. [Guinevere]
Rett Syndrome: A pervasive
developmental disorder affecting the gray matter of the brain, occurring exclusively in
females and present from birth; it is characterized by autistic behavior,
ataxia(uncoordinated movement), dementia, seizures, and loss of purposeful use of the
hands, with cerebral atrophy, mild hyperammonemia, and decreased levels of biogenic
amines.
Dear Guinevere: Yes, you've been through a lot - you sound
so tired and soul-weary - but, dear Guinevere, do not let your sadness separate you from
others and from God... I know that you feel isolated, that no one understands. You feel
that you've been given this burden to bear all alone. This is not true. There are good
people out there who are able and want to help you. But you must be the one to take that
first step. Please seek out the services of a counseling professional near where you
live.The world can still be a good place to be. With someone who cares by your side, your
burden can be made lighter. Why these things happen, it's hard to say. But do not look for
blame where none exists. It's not your fault, nor God's. God is not a source of
punishment, but, rather, the wellspring from which all hope and love derive.
... As for the afterlife, please read the many letters on this site which bear witness to
its existence. The physical world and the spiritual together make up the threads of
existence; to those who can see, there is but a thin veil between the two... And the
little ones: Age is something linked to the physical body, while, the soul itself is
ageless. Child or adult has no meaning in the eternal realm of the spirit. Know that you
and your daughter are now and forever linked as equal souls through love. These bonds of
love built here on earth are what give our life(however brief) its purpose and its reward.
The questions you ask are difficult, there are no easy answers. But, for now, you must
trust that with the healing effects of prayer and time, eventually, you will find peace
and will no longer feel the need to question why. Laura
Dear Laura:
I am a stay-at-home mom. We home school and have 6 kids, including a baby we lost October
1999. My youngest, Elizabeth, is a 5-year-old. She seemed to be going through the grieving
process normally (if that exists) until about 1 year ago. At that time, she became
extremely clingy. When I go to the bathroom she calls 3-5 times "Mom, where are
you?" When I go out to feed the animals or check the mail, she goes with me. If she
can see me, she is ok, otherwise she freaks out. I have even quit going to Sunday school
because she panics, crying and holding on to me when I try to drop her off. Although she
goes to sleep in her own bed, while I wait in a chair, she usually wakes up sometime
during the night and crawls in bed with me. My husband is a truck driver and is home only
about 3 nights a week. About once every 5 weeks, I get a half day off when my husband
keeps her and occasionally I can go to the store alone if my oldest daughter (17) is home
to watch her. This is starting to wear really thin and, of course, I want my daughter
(Elizabeth) to be secure, but she doesn't seem to be making much progress. I don't fuss at
her, just remind her that I won't leave her. When I ask her about this,she says she
is afraid that I will go to the hospital and die too, or that I will love another little
girl. Can you give me some advice? Also, it seems strange that this problem didn't occur
right after we lost our baby, but about 6 months later. Thanks. [K.W.]
Dear KW:
The reason that there was a delay in your daughter's symptoms is related to her ongoing
process of intellectual development. She, obviously, was aware of what was occuring in the
family with the death of the baby, but did not begin acting out until much later as her
cognitive awareness progressed. She is "better" able now to express her fears to
you, though much of this fear is acted out by her constant clinging to your side and need
for attention. BUT, then she did tell you most clearly that she is afraid of you
dying(abandonment) or being replaced in your affections. This is in keeping with her level
of development at age 4-6 when fears are centered around abandonment (as with very young
children) and (for the older child) a growing self-concept: Do they(family, friends,
classmates) love/like me? Can I do this or that like all the other kids? Do I measure up?
(Question: How much attention was shown to her at the time of her sibling's death? I know
that we all can get caught up in a time of crisis and exhibit a kind of tunnel vision. She
might have felt that she was not a very important part of the family while all this was
going on.)
Your daughter needs to regain some sense of predictability in her young world, some
feeling of control in her life - really, as do we all. I do not recommend that you
continue your strategy of giving in to her fears by remaining by her side at all times.
What I do recommend is that you tell her very clearly and kindly that you will be there
whenever she truly needs you. Initially, you may have to tell her when you are going to
leave the house and exactly when you will return, and - most importantly - stick very
close to your promise. She needs to see in very concrete, practical terms that you will
come back when you say you will. She needs to know that her world can be predictable and
safe. An aide in this would be to give her a small token to reassure her and make her feel
special, something tangible which, by touching, she can be reminded of your continuing
love and promise, such as an inexpensive necklace or bracelet. I know you are already
emotionally drained, but hang in there just a bit longer; with time and patience, this
soon should pass. Laura
Dear Laura:
I recently learned that someone I loved more than 40 years ago died. He was my "first
love." I was still in high school. He had just graduated from high school, and
I met him at church. We had a close, intense (as only the young can be) relationship for a
year. We laughed, we swam, we talked. He wanted us to marry. Then I had to move with my
parents to another state. It was a traumatic time for both of us. We stayed in touch for a
year and he reluctantly agreed that we should see others while we were so far apart. He
made the trip several times to see me. That next summer, I went to stay with my
grandmother back in my hometown for two weeks, and we were together then. I, being so
young and unable to give the commitment he desired, broke off the relationship but in some
way always loved him. It was just that I had so little control over my own life as a
teenager, and we were so far apart, that it was emotionally very difficult. He was
hurt; I was sorry. He called my grandmother to see about me and occasionally they
met, so eventually I knew he married. I thought of him often through the years. When I
went to my hometown - a metropolitan area - I'd check the phone book and see his name.
Sometimes, I thought I'd like to contact him but didn't want to cause a problem for him or
his family in any way. I felt if I ever saw him there'd still be a "connection."
I mean, I felt he'd care about me and my well-being as I cared for him.
Around twenty years ago, I felt a strong desire to contact him, but resisted. A few months
ago, I saw his nickname on a car in the town I moved to and have lived in for 40+ years.
This is too weird. I saw the car several times in a few days' time and haven't seen it
since. The nickname is so unusual that it seemed indeed strange to me. It prompted me to
do a search on the Internet ending in my discovery that he'd died two years ago after a
long illness. He'd remained married to the wife of his youth and they had three children,
which I was pleased to know. But I was so saddened about his illness and to know he died
in a nursing home at 63. I have been married all these years to the husband of my youth -
I married at 18. Foolish as it sounds, I am just devastated to know that my beloved
"friend" of so long ago is gone. I think I hoped that at some point we'd talk,
we'd know who each of us had become, that I'd hear about his life, children, etc. I wanted
to thank him for loving me the way he had and to say I was sorry for hurting him. I'm so
sad that the sadness overshadows everything, and this seems unreasonable and silly after
all these years. I know it is probably because he'll be forever the idyllic, perfect love
of my youth - and I feel foolish. I do believe that love lasts forever
and that on some level I have continued to love this person all my life even while I have
loved and been physically faithful to my husband. A younger friend of mine thinks seeing
his most unusual nickname in a custom decal on a car several times has some deeper
meaning. I also know now that when I had such a strong desire to contact him twenty years
ago, it was about the time his long illness and treatment, etc. started. But are
these things just coincidence and we look for hidden meaning? I want to believe
I'll see and know him and other loved ones in heaven (and that this will be possible
because the conflicts, resentments and jealousies of human feelings will be absent). I had
believed all my life that would be true. In recent years, people I love and respect have
told me they don't believe we'll know loved ones in heaven... that it's not about that but
about perfect peace, happiness, understanding, and love for God - and I believe that, too.
The timing (my youth) and other circumstances (moving away) were not right for my lost
love. I know that but how do I accept it? Is this normal? I don't want to become obsessed
with sadness or to become perpetually depressed. I believe that life is sad and hard but
that it also has great joy. I love my husband and my children and grandchildren. What is
wrong with me? Sincerely, Elizabeth
Dear Elizabeth: No,
there is nothing wrong with you. On the contrary, your story is proof that true love is
eternal. Strange, how even when the messages are so strong and frequent - as in your case
- we have been trained to doubt. Elizabeth, what you've been experiencing throughout the
years is not coincidence. That strong foundation of mutual love that you and he shared in
your youth has never faded. It remains and is the bond that will always hold your soul to
his. True love, when it does occur, lifts us. Life takes on a new, joyous meaning. We see
beyond the world's prejudices. We recognize the spiritual equality that joins us all.
Do not be sad that you never had that one, last meeting with the love of your youth. He
knows of your joys and your sorrows. He has always at some level been a part of your life,
and you, his. The messages that you have been receiving are so very clear. Know that
heaven is not a place for disappointment. Love will one day come full circle. For now,
know that there are many whose love you share on earth, as well as that one special angel
whose heart you stole so many years ago. Laura
Dear Laura:
My son, Jamie, was killed in an automobile crash on September 1st, 1996. I wonder to this
day why! There are so many questions I'd like to ask but, the main one is: How do I know
my son made it to heaven? This is a question I often ask God, but I still feel as if I've
not received my answer. Thank you so much for being there to talk to, because I need
someone. [Patricia]
Dear Patricia: You
must believe that your precious son is in heaven. How can it be that God's love for him
would be any less than yours? Why these things happen is a mystery, but what is not a
mystery is that we are never really separated from those we love. But, you may say, how
can this be? Patricia, you must understand that the spiritual and the physical together
make up the fabric of the universe. Your son is as close to you today as he was before,
but you need to look for signs of his presence now with your spiritual senses - your
intuition, if you will. I know that there have been times when you thought/felt/hoped that
maybe he was near. This is not an illusion. These have been the times when your sorrow has
ebbed, when your emotional defenses were down. This occurs when the mind is calm, when it
is open with a child-like acceptance of its surroundings; this is when the channels
between heaven and earth become apparent. Try looking for the subtle signs of your son's
presence, open your heart to the possibility. You can find peace again, once you allow
yourself to believe. Laura
Laura, it's Elizabeth yet again. I thought of my sister
whose rather caustic remark made me feel foolish about seeing my lost love's name on a car
... BUT she reminded me yesterday about an experience that she had 25 years ago that may
interest you. She was divorced after 18 years with three children almost grown. Her
high-school-age younger daughter and her son had decided to go to live with their dad, 200
miles away (that didn't last!). Incredibly sad and heartbroken, she lay across her bed
sobbing, alone in the house. Suddenly, she felt the comforting touch of someone patting
her shoulder. She said it startled her so that she stopped crying and lifted her head,
thinking someone had entered the room. The sensation was so real that she is
convinced to this day that it happened ... and we thought, "An angel?"
Dear Elizabeth: When
something so profound occurs that it is remembered vividly 25 years later, there can be no
doubting that it was real. But what was it? Was it an angel or some other spiritual
entity? ... While heaven's love surrounds us always, your sister needed something more
that day 25 years ago. The angelic hand which so lovingly touched her shoulder was a
definite manifestation that she was not alone. Again, was it an angel or, possibly, the
spirit of a departed loved one? mother, grandmother? Your sister will have to look within
her heart for the answer. In either case, she should take this as proof and as a comfort
that she has been and still is not alone in her journey here on earth. I would suggest
that, either through prayer or quiet meditation, she call upon that "someone"
who touched her so long ago; much wisdom can be gained by reaching out to the other,
higher side of our being. Laura
Dear Laura:
My wife has been dealing with depression for many years. In February, she had a
needle biopsy for a growth in her breast that was determined to be "negative."
After what the doctors had then called a "fibrous growth" continued to grow, she
recently had surgery to remove the growth. The lab report was slow in coming back...
but she had told me that she felt very good about this, and her physician told me that he
felt good about the surgery.
On Sunday after the surgery (Father's Day), she became angry at me over a multi-year feud
she has been having with our oldest son, and she stopped talking to me.
After speaking with the doctor on Monday morning (no lab results yet), I went to
work. Though I continued to communicate with her, she refused to speak to me or
communicate in writing. I asked her several times about the lab results and she would not
answer me.
I learned only yesterday that the lab results were that an "aggressive" form of
cancer was found. The doctor's advice was that she have surgery and chemotherapy
right away. Without letting me know anything about this at the time, she refused, and
instead said that she wanted to see another doctor about some problems (obviously less
critical) with her stomach. She has an appointment with the doctor about her stomach on
Tuesday, and refused to see the surgeon before then. I believe this "suicidal"
approach is because of her anger at me and several other family members over wounds that
should have healed long ago.
Please pray that she will 1) agree to treatment for the cancer this week, and 2) will be
completely physically healed so that we can together start the emotional healing process.
I fear that this lapse in time will cost her life - a greater expense than I am willing to
deal with right now. I feel as if I am grieving already. What do you suggest I
do that can help her to see I am there for her? Though I am obviously selfish in my desire
not to lose her, I am also extremely concerned for her. Please pray for us both. [anon.]
Dear anon: Try
to arrange for a second party to mediate for you: someone she trusts. Time is of the
essence now and should not be wasted with petty squabbling. Your wife may be acting
irrationally because of her ongoing depression, or she may be putting off confronting her
cancer due to fear. In either case, she needs to be encouraged to seek treatment - the
sooner, the better. And, yes, both of you are in our prayers. Laura [Good news below]
Dear Laura: I sent you a message before about my wife, and her
problem with cancer. She had hidden the diagnosis from me for about a month, and she
was refusing treatment until after getting her stomach problems resolved. Well, I am
writing you back to share good news. About two weeks ago, the stomach problems were
resolved, and she agreed to proceed with treatment. She had a radical modified
mastectomy on Wednesday of last week, and they did a "lat" reconstruction during
the same surgery. She is home and doing great, but the best news of all came this
morning from the pathology report. The lymph nodes that were removed during and
biopsied after the mastectomy were late this morning determined to all be free of any
signs of any presence of cancer. The surgeon who performed the mastectomy had already
told me that he saw no evidence of any tumors in any of the breast tissue he had removed.
I am writing you about all of this to let you know that your encouragement helped
me. When I was not able to get someone else involved in getting her to agree to seek
treatment, I had to be firm but gentle in my persistent encouragement to her to do
whatever it took to get to the goal of treatment for the breast cancer. I thank you for
your encouragement and the prayers of all who read the anonymous letter I wrote
before. May God bless each and every one who prayed for us. [anon.]
 |